How Large A Portion?

Ouch! You have just suffered an injury while at work, and therefore may file a workers’ compensation claim.  You are in your mid-40’s and the injury is to your back.  You had noticed your back hurting a bit before the injury (probably from just getting older) but it was nowhere near the pain that you are now experiencing since the work injury.  Not to mention you had that old embarrassing lower back injury that you suffered during a picnic whiffleball game a few months ago, which you have since pretty much fully recovered from.  But what should these other aches and pains have to do with your new injury?  After all, if it wasn’t for the new work injury, you would still be able to work!

That is absolutely true.  However, when it comes time to determine the amount of Permanent Disability associated with your back injury, the doctor will attempt to determine just that:  how much of the disability was caused by the work injury and not other contributing factors.  This is called apportionment in workers’ compensation.

The doctor will attempt to apportion your Permanent Disability.  Using the example above, the doctor could determine that 80% of your disability is a result of your work injury, while 10% is due to “degenerative changes” (the back pain you noticed before) and 10% to your whiffleball-related injury.  This is when you say, “But that isn’t fair!  If it wasn’t for the work injury I wouldn’t have any noticeable disability!”  You’re right, but that is just the way the law and the labor code are written at the moment, and we’re stuck with it.

Insurance companies are also beginning to try to apportion an injured worker’s inability to get back to work after the injury to other factors besides the injury itself.  Again, you will correctly shout from the rooftop that “but if it wasn’t for my work injury I would still have my job!”  However, insurance companies are increasingly making the argument that not all of someone’s inability to find a job is related to the work injury.  They put forward that the economic climate is even preventing healthy people from finding work, that the injured worker may not be looking at all available jobs, that the job the injured worker was employed in is now more and more rare for anyone who is looking for work, injured or not.  Simply put, they are looking for other things to blame your inability to find a job on than your work-related injury.

Rodman J Martin

Fist of all, if you’re at this point in your workers’ compensation claim where you have to answer this question, congratulations!  You have most likely already had your deposition taken and have been to multiple medical evaluations.  You are now at the settlement stage.  However, there are 2 types of settlement: Stipulations with a Request for Award (Stips) and Compromise and Release (C&R).

Stipulations (a fancy word for “agreements”) with a Request for Award is a settlement that allows for the future medical care associated with your work injuries to remain open.  In other words, the workers’ compensation insurance carrier still has to pay for your medical after you sign the settlement.  In fact, they will be on the hook for it as long as you need it (it’s lifetime medical, but only on the work injury).  However, they can still send treatment requests from your doctor through Utilization Review (UR), which is where they determine to reject or deny a particular treatment based on their determination of the treatment’s “medical necessity.”  In other words, even though the medical care is left open, they can still review it and deny it if they don’t think it’s necessary.  Also, with a Stip settlement you can re-open your case within 5 years from the date of injury if you feel that your work injury has gotten worse and has resulted in new and further disability since the settlement.

The Compromise and Release (C&R) is where the insurance company issues you a tax free lump sum check in exchange for being relieved of liability (taken off the hook) for future medical care associated with the work injury.  In other words, the benefit to you is that you receive all of the settlement money at once, while the benefit to the insurance company is that they no longer have to worry about paying your doctors.  The lump sum check often takes into account the benefits associated with your permanent disability, the estimated cost of your future medical care, and the value of giving up the right to reopen your case.  Lastly, if you are still working at the job you got injured at, the employer most likely will not be agreeable to settling by way of C&R.  The reason is because of you settle by C&R and go to work the next and injure the same body part, they are on the hook again for medical treatment of that body part.  It defeats the purpose of them agreeing to enter into that type of settlement; not having to be liable for the medical care in the future.

Which one you choose is of course ultimately your decision to make.  If you know that you are going to require a lot of medical treatment because of the injury and do not have any other type of insurance, you will probably lean toward leaving the future medical open.  If you do not get a lot of treatment or are getting by without it and don’t anticipate it being a problem in the future, you might want to settle with a C&R.

By RODMAN J MARTIN, esq

As your workers’ comp claim comes to a close (it does actually happen), you may be asked to provide information to the insurance carrier regarding Medicare information.  This will most likely be the case if you have a lot of life experience (are older).  If you’re young the only time it would typically be requested is if you are suffering from kidney failure.

The bottom line is you will have yet one more form to fill before you can put your claim to bed.  This is because the federal government wants to know how much money has been allocated for the future medical care of your work injury.  They do not want to pay for something that is considered in the settlement of your workers’ comp claim:  the cost associated with your future medical care.

This is all to “coordinate benefits” between Medicare and the workers’ comp insurance carrier.  Remember, in workers’ comp you are receiving benefits associated with your injury, not damages like in a personal injury lawsuit.

If you are presented with a “Medicare questionnaire form” don’t panic.  Simply read the instructions and fill it out.  You only need to provide your social security number if the Medicare claim number is unavailable.  You will be required to sign the form before you send it in.

To summarize, if you are less than 65 and have been receiving Social Security Disability for 2 or more years, or if you are 65 or older, or if you are suffering from kidney failure, Medicare is going to want to know about your workers’ compensation claim.

Rodman Martin, Esq